Responding to a tax Instalment Reminder from the CRA (February 2021)
Sometime during the month of February, millions of Canadians will receive mail from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). That mail, a “Tax Instalment Reminder”, will set out the amount of installment payments of income tax to be paid by the recipient taxpayer by March 15 and June 15 of this year.
Receiving an Instalment Reminder from the CRA won’t be a surprise for many recipients who have paid tax by installments during previous tax years. For others, however, the need to make tax payments by installment is a new and unfamiliar concept. That’s because for most Canadians — certainly most who earn their income through employment — the payment of income tax throughout the year is an automatic and largely invisible process, requiring no particular action on the part of the employee/taxpayer. Federal and provincial income taxes, along with Canada Pension Plan (CPP) contributions and Employment Insurance (EI) premiums, are deducted from each employee’s income and the amount deposited to an employee’s bank account is the net amount remaining after such taxes, contributions, and premiums are deducted and remitted on the employee’s behalf to the CRA. While no one likes having to pay taxes, having those taxes paid “off the top” in such an automatic way is, relatively speaking, painless. Such is not, however, the case for the sizeable minority of Canadians who pay their income taxes by way of tax installments.
The CRA’s decision to send an Instalment Reminder to certain taxpayers isn’t an arbitrary one. Rather, an Instalment Reminder is generated when sufficient income tax has not been deducted from payments made to that taxpayer throughout the year. Put more technically, an Instalment Reminder will be issued by the CRA where the amount of tax which was or will be owed when filing the annual tax return is more than $3,000 in the current (2021) tax year and either of the two previous (2019 or 2020) tax years. Essentially, the requirement to pay by installments will be triggered where the amount of tax withheld from the taxpayer’s income for the year is at least $3,000 less than their total tax owed for 2021 and either 2019 or 2020. For residents of Quebec, that threshold amount is $1,800.
Such obligation arises on a regular basis for those who are self-employed, of course, and generally for those whose income is largely derived from investments. The group of recipients of a tax installment reminder often also includes retired Canadians, especially the newly retired, for two reasons. First, while most employees have income from only a single source — their paycheque — retirees often have multiple sources of income, including Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS) payments, private retirement savings and, sometimes, employer-provided pensions. And, while income tax is deducted automatically from one’s paycheque, that’s not the case for most sources of retirement income. Relatively few new retirees realize that it’s necessary to make arrangements to have tax deducted “at source” from either their government source income (like CPP or OAS payments) or private retirement income like pensions or registered retirement income fund withdrawals, and to make sure that the total amount of those deductions is sufficient to pay the total tax bill for the year. It is that group of individuals who may be surprised and puzzled by the arrival of an unfamiliar Instalment Reminder from the CRA. However, no matter what kind of income a taxpayer has received, or why sufficient tax has not been deducted at source, the options open to a taxpayer who receives such an Instalment Reminder are the same.
First, the taxpayer can pay the amounts specified on the Reminder, by the March and June payment due dates. Choosing this option will mean that the taxpayer will not face any interest or penalty charges, even if the amount paid by installments throughout the year turns out to be less than the taxes actually payable for 2021. If the total of installment payments made during 2021 turn out to more than the taxpayer’s total tax liability for the year, he or she will, of course, receive a refund when the annual tax return is filed in the spring of 2022.
Second, the taxpayer can make installment payments based on the amount of tax which was owed for the 2020 tax year. (Generally speaking, such amount will be known once the taxpayer has completed his or her return for 2020). Where a taxpayer’s income has not changed significantly between 2020 and 2021 and his or her available deductions and credits remain the same, the likelihood is that total tax liability for 2021 will be slightly less than it was in 2020, as the result of the indexation of both income tax brackets and tax credit amounts.
Third, the taxpayer can estimate the amount of tax which he or she will owe for 2021 and can pay installments based on that estimate. Where a taxpayer’s income will decrease significantly from 2020 to 2021, such that his or her tax bill will also be substantially reduced, this option can make the most sense.
A taxpayer who elects to follow the second or third options outlined above will not face any interest or penalty charges if there is no tax payable when the return for the 2021 tax year is filed in the spring of 2022. However, should installments paid have been late or insufficient in amount, the CRA will impose interest charges, at rates which are higher than current commercial rates (the rate charged for the first quarter of 2021 — until March 31, 2021 — is 5%). As well, where interest charges are levied, such interest is compounded daily, meaning that on each successive day, interest is levied on the previous day’s interest. It is also possible for the CRA to levy penalties for overdue or insufficient installments, but that is done only where the amount of installment interest charged for the year is more than $1,000.
Most Canadian taxpayers are understandably disinclined to pay their taxes any sooner than absolutely necessary. However, ignoring an Instalment Reminder is never in the taxpayer’s best interests. Those who don’t wish to involve themselves in the intricacies of tax calculations can simply pay the amounts specified in the Reminder. The more technical-minded (or those who want to ensure that they are paying no more than absolutely required, and are willing to take the risk of having to pay interest on any shortfall) can avail themselves of the second or third options outlined above.
To help taxpayers make a decision on how to respond to an Instalment Reminder, detailed information on the installment payment system is available on the CRA website at https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/individuals/topics/about-your-tax-return/making-payments-individuals/paying-your-income-tax-instalments.html.